Going Car-Free

Four years ago, I rid myself of having cable (and two years ago, I ditched owning a TV altogether). It has easily been one of the best choices of my life: I’ve been more productive personally and professionally, had time for continued learning across several verticals and an amplified drive to create art.
Freeing myself of TV was just step one in simplifying my life. Step two, naturally, was removing my car. Today I wanted to share my experience (so far) going car-free. To summarize: it’s nothing short of spectacular.
With my recent move to San Francisco I was able to put this into action. I had initially narrowed my choice of new cities to San Francisco and New York for several reasons, including the fact they are both extremely livable without a car. Also personally I enjoy both cities. But beyond that: they are true innovation hubs.
I’m not just saying this from opinion – in the map below, Richard Florida plots the top 10 US metros on each of the basic density measures, charting human capital, creative class workers, artistic and cultural creatives, patented innovations, and high-tech workers per square kilometer:

I show this map for the simple reason that not only are New York and San Francisco both top cities in America – due to their high population densities of innovators and great public transit they are perfect for car-free lifestyles because you’re going to be in close proximity to a wealth of smart, creative individuals. The serendipity of connection in these circumstances increases greatly when you’re not isolated in your car.
Aside from this, following are some of the more specific reasons I’m excited to be car-free.
Time optimization
While in Minneapolis, my commute took about 30 minutes in the morning and around 45 minutes at night. In many cases even longer. Conservatively, that’s 5.2% of my day, every day, gone forever. Certainly I made good use of that time enjoying new artists as well as interesting podcasts, but being stuck in traffic still costs time and causes stress.
A quote shared in a recent post on Zen Habits discussing this topic hits the nail on the head:
‘Life is too short for traffic.’ ~Dan Bellack
Further, owning a car requires paying bills, getting gas, taking the car in for service, paying car insurance, finding parking, cleaning and a slew of other issues that all require your time. As I noted in a 2007 post: time is your most precious resource. Anything you can do to optimize your time is highly worth considering.
I chose a strategic location to live that would be close enough to work for walking yet still gain time. My new commute is .8 miles or approximately a 15 minute walk at most, which means I’m gaining back 3.1% of my day back M-F. Doesn’t sound like much? This equals +195.75 hours (+8.1 days) per year of driving time I’m getting back.
What about recurring tasks like grocery shopping? Well again, planning here helped: there’s a grocery store on my way home. Without having to worry about a car, this works out even nicer than a commute where I had to not only go out of my way to the store, but also find parking.
Health/environment
Walking every day to work not only transforms my commute from painful to pleasant, there are health benefits from building exercise into my daily routine. In college I lived about a mile off campus, but purposefully chose to walk most days as opposed to taking the bus. I recalled how nice of an experience this was while choosing to get rid of my car before moving to San Francisco. As some days are naturally too busy to get to the gym, having exercise as an unavoidable part of the routine is a good thing. Also since I fly a lot, I feel good about not owning a car as this helps reduce my carbon footprint.
Cars are expensive
As noted above – not only do gas, parking, insurance, etc. require your time, they require money. I ran the numbers and it actually makes far more sense to rent when necessary as opposed to own. With innovative services such as Zipcar, I think for many city-dwellers this is an appealing option. Further, from a travel standpoint, public transit or even a cab to the airport is way more cost-effective than parking.
City exploration, serendipitous interactions
You miss so much when driving. Small shops are passed by without second thought. Other cars and pedestrians are forever anonymous. By walking through a city you see and interact with everything and everyone around you. It is a more serendipitous experience and especially enjoyable living in a cultural hearth.
Conclusion
All of this is so counter-intuitive to my mindset growing up. I couldn’t wait to own a car, it was a right of passage and a symbol (and enabler) of freedom. Living in suburbs that was true. But I’ve come to the realization that, at least with my life goals and the desire to pursue my career, learning, art, and sharing ideas with you, a car isn’t necessary and could actually work against that.
I thought it might take time to adjust to not owning a car, but I’m already enjoying it quite a bit. When living in uptown Minneapolis and downtown Fort Lauderdale I almost never drove on weekends so it’s not too much of an adjustment. I can’t say I won’t own one again at some point in life. But right now it’s a lot nicer not having it.
What about you? Ever thought about going car-free? Think you could do it?
image credit: Shutterstock






Katie Morse replied | Dec 1, 2010 (2 comments)
I moved to NYC a few years ago and got rid of my car as well. Now, I LOVE driving – but I hated owning a car and being chained to it for basic things like grocery shopping, commuting, seeing friends, etc.
I haven’t yet had an excuse to rent a Zipcar in NYC, and I’ve been more than happy to use the subways, buses, trains and other available modes of transportation (ferries, anyone?) to get where I need to go.
My commute went from 15 minutes of traffic and worry (I was in a fairly serious car accident about 3 years ago, so was a bit of a nervous driver after that), to 25 minutes of listening to music and reading in my own little world – I much prefer this commute to the former and don’t mind waiting a few minutes for a train if I know it will get me there without much hassle.
I, like you, tend to fly a lot and also like the fact that while I’m being more physically active, I’m doing what I can to help the environment. I also don’t miss the expense of owning a car and as an additional benefit, people always seem to get worried about you driving if you haven’t in a few months… so even when I’m in a situation where I could drive, I usually end up just riding!
Happy to see that you’re settling in to San Francisco! NY would have loved to have you here!
-Katie
Adam Singer replied | Dec 2, 2010 (597 comments)
SF won out — but I’ll def have a visit to NY next year as I have several contacts there. We’ll have to do coffee sometime, Katie.
Bob replied | Dec 1, 2010 (1 comment)
I share your disdain for the car culture. You may be interested in a couple of articles I’ve written on car ownership, on this page: http://www.suburbanshift.com/category/cars/ , in particular How Cars Rob Americans of their Retirement and the Problem of commuting.
Adam Singer replied | Dec 2, 2010 (597 comments)
Thanks for sharing Bob – reading through some of the articles now, good stuff!
Greg Faherty replied | Dec 1, 2010 (1 comment)
After living in NYC for 10 years, when I moved to Seattle about 4 years ago I was actually looking forward to having a car. Recently I have started commuting to work by foot/ferry and it struck me how much I missed getting to know a city by foot. I feel like I have learned more about the city in the past 6 months on foot than I have in the past 3.5 years by car.
Adam Singer replied | Dec 2, 2010 (597 comments)
Yes, you really get to know a city intimately by walking it. It’s a totally different lifestyle. Love it so far.
Albert Maruggi replied | Dec 1, 2010 (1 comment)
nice, wait let me ask how many kids do you have living with you?
Adam Singer replied | Dec 1, 2010 (597 comments)
Nope – no kids :)
Craig Oda replied | Dec 3, 2010 (1 comment)
I’ve been without a TV for 5 or 6 years. I also lived for 8 years without a car in Tokyo.
However, I can’t imagine living without a car in my current situation as father and husband. Life without a car would be fairly limiting, especially to pursue recreational outdoor activities like fishing, surfing, snowboarding at Tahoe, going to soccer games.
Ron Zeligzon replied | Dec 7, 2010 (3 comments)
I have lived in NYC for over 3 years. I haven’t owned a car in over 6 years. To be honest with you, I didn’t think I would miss owning a car, the expenses, the headache, but sometimes I just need to get out of the city and wish I owned a car that was parked in a garage in the city. Plus public transportation in NYC…..Most pretty inefficient. Adam, seems like you made the better choice by moving to SF.
Rachel – Avaguide replied | Dec 16, 2010 (8 comments)
Hey good luck! You’re a risk taker and a good one too :) Anyway for now I don’t think I can still rid of the TV and a vehicle since I have kids. But one day I hope I can.