Digital Marketing Strategy Development Part 1: Image And Identity

Last Monday I shared 12 common problems associated with digital marketing strategy development. Since I’m not one to talk problems and not offer solutions, over the next few weeks I will address these problems one by one.
The first problem discussed was as follows:
1. Lack of understanding what image you are trying to project
You need to understand this from the start and have a style behind the image, along with substance to back it up. It also needs to resonate with key audiences. Most are not consciously sculpting how they are perceived or creating any reason they should get noticed in the first place.
The solution to this is obvious: spend time defining what image/identity you want to project, and infuse it with your communications, design and branding across platforms.
But how can you know what image should you project in the first place?
Understanding your audience is step one. But to reach them in any kind of meaningful way, you need to go further: you must be your audience. It is not enough merely to study them, you’re only flirting with the necessary insights. If you’re a strategist or consultant but always an outsider you will never achieve the level of insight available to insiders. It’s the same reason those not part of a generation almost always get their analysis of that generation wrong.
A quote from Robert Greene’s new book, the 50th law, clarifies the logic behind this:
Understand: in this day and age, to reach people you must have access to their inner lives – their frustrations, aspirations, resentments. To do so, you must crush as must distance as possible between you and your audience. You enter their spirit and absorb it from within. Their way of looking at things becomes yours, and when you re-create it in some form of work, it has life. What shocks and excites you will then have the same effect on them. This requires a degree of fearlessness and an open spirit. You are not afraid to have your whole personality shaped by these intense interactions. You assume a radical equality with the public, giving voice to people’s ideas and desires. What you produce will naturally connect, in a deep way.
Being your target will give you the perspective necessary to know what image/identity will actually resonate. Companies (and professionals) willing and able to put themselves in the shoes of their targets will always win against those who hide in castles and view things from the “expert” perspective. Being an expert is well and good, but ultimately you’ll lose against others who may not even be as smart but have the advantage of an insider perspective. I’d always rather be able to empathize with my audience than have those in ivory towers telling me how I should connect with them.
I’m a coffee lover and web user. I had an unfair advantage when developing the java beta test. I knew both audiences inside and out, so marketing to them was effortless. If I get a client or brand in an industry I’m unfamiliar with, I try their product/technology and become a member of the relevant communities prior to developing strategies. I did the same thing before developing my own identity in the marketing industry. I wasn’t first, but I didn’t need to be – I became an active member of the existing communities and as an insider it became clear what path to take and the strategy necessary, including what image and identity I should project.
Again and again during identity development researching isn’t enough when others are actually participating. You’ll miss the mark when the path can be obvious and apparent. If any part of your marketing strategy is not both obvious and apparent to you, you’re probably trying to force it even if data exists behind it. Become your audience instead of just studying them and clarity of the image you should convey will be a byproduct.
image credit: Aleksey Fursov via Shutterstock









Josh Braaten replied | Jan 11, 2010 (30 comments)
The approach you recommend is the tried-and-true, blood-sweat-and-tears way of understanding your audience. There are also some effective short cuts you could have taken. For example, a survey or poll could help you understand what the current problems are within your market. Problems you could solve. Great post!
Adam Singer replied | Jan 11, 2010 (550 comments)
Hey Josh – yes, you have a point. It is work. But unfortunately, audience data does not necessarily provide the strategic insight available to those who are actually members of an audience. Especially when it comes to more specific groups where there is a clear separation of insiders and outsiders. Being a member of such a group gives something data can never provide: an ability to empathize with that audience. I’m not saying you can’t use polls/data/surveys to help – you can. But empathizing is so underrated in business in marketing strategy. And that’s exactly why it works, almost no one goes that far.
Nishant Gupta replied | Jun 17, 2010 (1 comment)
Hi Adam,
No doubt Its nice post.But correct me if i m wrong.
Being an audience rather than studying them gives you clarity of the Image as a byproduct, but dont you think that when you are going to talk about a larger group then their must be different kind of perceptions and approach towards the image.So I thought it is very difficult to judge by only your perception on the behalf of whole audience.
Walt Goshert replied | Jan 11, 2010 (1 comment)
Being your audience today online requires being authentic and transparent too.
It’s one thing to understand and empathize with your market, but if at any point, your message disconnects, you’re in trouble.
Case in point: The Obama Campaign sold the concept of Hope and Change brilliantly via social media during the campaign. They seem to have dropped the approach while in office.
John Bradley replied | Jan 11, 2010 (3 comments)
Thanks Adam. Another inspirational post.
Adam Cleaver replied | Jan 14, 2010 (1 comment)
Great post, Adam – thanks! The tension between image and identity is where the real creativity begins to sparkle. The people we’re trying to reach have many different online personalities, which they reveal and use in different communities they adhere to both online and offline. Our job as digital strategists is to make sure we touch with them wherever they engage – that mean our ideas must be simple, subtle and innovative.
Carl Phelps replied | Jan 15, 2010 (2 comments)
At iWrite Marketing we made a strategic decision about the nature of the business based on this concept. Although we wanted to move away from consulting to provide services that are more scalable, we decided to always keep doing some consulting. We want to understand first-hand what it’s like in the trenches for our customers.
How could we teach people marketing if we weren’t actually doing it with some clients?